Louis Proyect: The Unrepentant Marxist

May 28, 2007

The Most Important Fish in the Sea

Filed under: Ecology — louisproyect @ 6:09 pm

With its putrid smell, bony flesh and rancid oily taste, the menhaden would seem the least likely candidate for “The Most Important Fish in the Sea,” the title of H. Bruce Franklin’s brilliant new environmentalist study. But Franklin is not being ironic. The menhaden is the most important fish in the sea if you understand its ecological purpose.

While it is understandable that groups like Greenpeace would take up the cause of sea creatures at the top of the food chain, like the great whales or the bluefin tuna, Franklin understands that without the easily dismissed menhaden, those above it on the food chain do not stand a chance. This includes the human race as well, since the menhaden is particularly suited to cleaning up plankton-ridden waters. As one of the few marine specimens that thrive on microscopic plant life or phyloplanton, it is uniquely positioned to purify waters that have become virtual swamps as a result of the massive influx of nitrogen-based fertilizers from farms, lawns and golf courses. With much of the Gulf of Mexico having been turned into a vast dead zone by fertilizer run-off from the Mississippi River, there is a drastic need for the humble menhaden.

The villain in “The Most Important Fish in the Sea” is industrial fishing in general and a particularly odious company called Omega Protein, whose website informs us that they “market a variety of products derived from menhaden, an inedible fish found in abundant quantities in coastal waters off the U.S. mid-Atlantic and Gulf Coasts.” It might be inedible to human beings, but fish love to eat them. Franklin explains that what makes them unappealing to human beings has an irresistible appeal to prized food fish, including the striped bass and the bluefish. Once the menhaden eat phytoplankton, they convert it into omega-3 fatty acids that all living creatures require but are available from only limited sources, such as flaxseed, soybeans and walnuts. Unfortunately, the striped bass and the bluefish cannot stroll into the local grocery store to pick up a bag of walnuts.

Reading Omega Protein’s website, one would get the impression that they are mainly in the health food business. “Omega Protein is the nation’s largest producer of Omega-3 fish oil, protein rich fish meal, and fish solubles.” What they don’t tell you is that most of what they produce ends up as chicken or pig feed. Chickens and pigs of course can flourish on other foodstuffs, but the striped bass and the bluefish cannot. Like most corporations, Omega has one and only one goal and that is to make a profit. The top stock holders could probably care less if the ocean was turned into a vast dead zone as long as they are prospering. As a symbol of the irrationality of the capitalist system and the looming environmental crisis that threatens all life, it is difficult to imagine a more cold-blooded and criminal outfit than Omega.

Omega was originally a subsidiary of the Zapata Corporation that was launched by George H.W Bush in 1953 as Zapata Oil. It sold off Omega in 2006 to Wilber L. Ross, a leveraged buyout expert. So it should be obvious where this outfit inherited its corporate ethics. If they could make money processing human flesh, they probably would.

H. Bruce Franklin first found out about the menhaden plight on salt water fishing expeditions off the New Jersey coast and in Chesapeake Bay, where Omega still has the right to use industrial fishing techniques to catch millions of the endangered menhaden. Deprived of the menhaden, the local game fish were showing signs of malnutrition:

This first fish looked healthy and normal enough to me, though I wasn’t used to seeing stripers this small being kept (the minimum Chesapeake size was eighteen inches, compared to the New Jersey minimum then of twenty-four inches, and now of twenty-eight inches). But Joe pointed out a small, rather unremarkable lesion near the anus, something I would have missed. This rockfish was the healthiest-looking we caught, however, except for one. The next fish, with bright red open sores gnawing deep into its side and belly, gave me a taste of that revulsion Jim must have felt back in 1997. One after the other, we caught diseased rockfish, each with horrifying symptoms.

If Omega Corporation only considers the menhaden in terms of what Karl Marx called “exchange value”, the original inhabitants of the New World–being primitive communists–were far more tuned in to its “use value”. They understood that the menhaden and other fish had enormous value as fertilizer and taught the pilgrims to bury them near corn. The Narragansett Indians called them munnawhatteaûg, which meant “fertilizer” or “that which manures”.

Not only are the menhaden useful as fertilizer, their oil can be used in the same way that whale oil was used in the 1800s–as a lubricant and as fuel. Not surprisingly, this led to the same kind of industrialized fishing techniques that came close to wiping out the whale. The menhaden were also reduced to a relative handful as vast purse nets in offshore waters on the Atlantic Coast yielded billions of fish. When alarms were raised about their possible extinction, the 19th century versions of Julian Simon dismissed them as chicken-little stories as Franklin’s epigraph to chapter five (“The Death of Fish and the Birth of Ecology”) would indicate:

I believe, then, that the cod fishery, the herring fishery, the pilchard fishery, the mackerel fishery, and probably all the great sea fisheries, are inexhaustible; that is to say, that nothing we do-seriously affects the number of the fish. And any attempt to regulate these fisheries seems consequently, from the nature of the case, to be useless.

–Thomas Henry Huxley, 1883

Considering the New York Times’s long-standing record of hewing closely to the agenda of corporate America, it is totally to be expected that they would repeat Huxley’s argument. When evidence began to mount in the early 1880s that the menhaden were being fished into extinction, the newspaper of record tried to get the commercial fishing industry off the hook:

It has been shown over and over again that man’s take of the sea fishes is utterly insignificant when the whole bulk of the fish is considered. Predaceous fish and birds, all the natural enemies of the fish, destroy more perhaps in a single hour than man captures in the year.

Although most of H. Bruce Franklin’s impressive scholarship is focused on the records of newspaper, magazine, industry associations and government agencies over the past 125 years or so, he does make one foray into popular culture that demonstrates this scholar’s eclectic and multifaceted approach (he has written on science fiction). He notes that a Simpson’s episode from 1997 very possibly alluded to the menhaden crisis. C. Montgomery Burns, the nuclear power plant owner that employs Homer Simpson and an all-round villain, launched a new business that sounds a lot like Omega. Trying to pull the wool over Homer’s daughter Lisa, a committed environmentalist and vegetarian, he has come up with something called “Li’l Lisa’s Patented Animal Slurry”, a high-protein feed for farm animals, insulation for low-income housing, a powerful explosive, and a top-notch engine coolant. When Lisa tells Burns that he is up to something evil, he responds, “I don’t understand. Pigs need food, engines need coolant, dynamiters need dynamite…and not a single sea creature was wasted.”

Considering H. Bruce Franklin’s long-time involvement with Herman Melville studies (he was the Program Director of the Melville Society in 1978 to 1979), his decision to write about the menhaden appears consistent with his own approach to Melville. Along with CLR James, Franklin is convinced that “Moby Dick” is a quintessential indictment of American capitalism. As one might expect, “The Most Important Fish in the Sea” is constructed around a rigorous historical materialist methodology and a sure command of the economic data.

If this wasn’t enough to recommend this powerful and insightful book, there is also the beauty of the prose that takes on Melvillian dimensions on page after page, especially the opening paragraphs of “The Most Important Fish in the Sea,” which is very likely the most important book you will read this year:

First you see the birds—gulls and terns wheeling overhead, then swooping down to a wide expanse of water dimpled as though by large raindrops and glittering with silver streaks. The sea erupts with frothy splashes, some from the diving birds, others from foot-long fish with deeply forked tails frantically hurling themselves out of the water, only to fall back into their tightly packed school. More and more birds materialize as if from nowhere, and the air rings with their shrill screams. Boats too begin to converge on the scene: the boiling cloud of birds has told anglers everywhere within view that a school of menhaden, perhaps numbering in the tens of thousands, is being ravaged by a school of bluefish.

Attacking from below and behind to slash the menhaden bodies with their powerful jaws, the razor-toothed blues are in a killing frenzy, gorging themselves with the severed backs and bellies of their prey, some killing even when they are too full to eat, some vomiting half-digested pieces so they can kill and eat again. Terns skim gracefully over the surface with their pointed bills down, dipping to pluck bits of flesh and entrails from the bloody swirls. Gulls plummet and flop heavily into the water, where a few splash about and squabble noisily over larger morsels. As some lift with their prizes, the squabbles turn aerial and a piece occasionally falls back into the water, starting a new round of shrieking skirmishes. Hovering high above the other birds, a male osprey scans for targets beneath the surface, then suddenly folds its gull-shaped wings and power-dives through the aerial tumult, extends its legs and raises its wings high over its head an instant before knifing into the water in a plume of spray, emerges in another plume, and laboriously flaps its four-foot wingspan as it slowly climbs and soars away with a writhing menhaden held headfirst in its talons. Beneath the blues, iridescent weakfish begin to circle, snapping at small lumps sinking from the carnage. Farther below, giant but toothless striped bass gobble tumbling heads and other chunks too big for the mouths of the weakfish. From time to time, bass muscle their way up through the blues, swallow whole menhaden alive, and propel themselves back down with their broom-like tails, leaving telltale swirls on the surface. On the mud below, crabs scuttle to scavenge on leftovers.


  1. In this case, (has) the number of inhabitants increased faster than the food and the accommodations necessary to preserve them in health?

    Comment by $ — May 29, 2007 @ 7:24 pm

  2. If you are speaking of fish, this is obviously the case. At the current rate, the oceans will be stripped of the most important fish by the middle of the century. If you are talking about human beings, it is a bit more complicated. Technology can find all sorts of substitutes but we really need to struggle for a sustainable environment, which obviously can only be realized under socialism.

    Comment by louisproyect — May 29, 2007 @ 7:28 pm

  3. ….

    I’ll have to check-out this book.


    Socialism is the only way to have people come first. We agree there.

    However my inept young America senses fail here.. so allow me to play the ‘sophist’/’Devil’s advocate’:

    In this case, helping mother nature, or ensuring the survival of the human race via a [“sustainable development of the earth” (in the words of UNESCO)] might be developing outside the legit need for a safe and sustainable ecosystem.

    …It takes a lot of capital to be environmentally friendly, these days.

    That considered, perhaps some, ruling class, people abuse environmentalism as cover for hatred of the poor masses, or at least an excuse to eliminate elements therein whose exploitation has been made unnecessary by the very technological advancement that necessitated their existance as fodder for the industrial revolutions.

    So now in the west we have the PRC and other unevenly developed capitalisms doing the manufacturing for us…..so…. Ted Kennedy&Al Gore and other such ivied liberals (cough) simply must enjoy Marthas Vinyard without all of those trailer parks firing coal power plants, filling septic tanks, smoking cowboy killers and driving around 81′ Fords w/o emissions checks..fucking redneck pollutant vermin whose unnecessary existance is being commodified and thus protected by the eeeevvvviiillll neo-reganite burns-esque Bushish profiteering proprietor swine.

    Shorter me: The First comment twas’ a direct quote from a high ranking officer within the British East India Company….name starts with a M, ends with an s….funny that y’all agree.

    Comment by $ — May 29, 2007 @ 11:08 pm

  4. Fine piece on the mossbunker. As long time fishermen on the sound and out of Montauk,my brother and I began noting changes in the bottom fish–we one day open a cod to find the meat grey rather than white. The number and rythms of the menhaden have also changed. But anyone who has fished over the years knows these things. I have been fishing with my friend Fred in the southern Bahamas for years where the long lines have decimated the tuna, and the very increase in water temperature had blanched the reefs, changed the whole ecology–in certain parts of those water one now has to be afrais of sea-lice, like noseeums, blackflies that bite the flesh and so one must wear a wet suit. Sick seas. We are plagued by the capacity of the species for denial, a reluctance to see the world as it is. Good article, Louis, about an important book.

    Comment by Paul Pines — June 3, 2007 @ 7:03 pm

  5. Hm… Some of the cetaceans, e.g., the orcas, might be top predators, but others, viz., the balenoptera such as the blue or the fin or the humpback, feed on the small critters what feed on the phytoplankton, tho’ mostly in cold waters such as those in the artic and antartic. Maybe we could introduce the rest of that food chain into the Gulf and get the big whales to help take care of the problem….. 🙂

    Comment by Paul Lyon — June 24, 2007 @ 10:16 am

  6. outstanding

    Comment by Brian McKenna — April 8, 2009 @ 7:49 pm

  7. I have made a study of Marxism aka socialism throughout history . Strangely, all I found were wrecks and ruination of nations and cultures when it was employed with any zeal. I would think that if it worked it would have worked by now as it was well under weigh in the middle 1800’s. Nasty bit that socialism. It doesn’t work because it expects men and women to act and behave ways that are outside of their nature. Silly. Who said….. The only thing shared equally is the misery it causes. Oh yeah …. the clothing…. oh my socialist runway models? The cheap and shabby Maoist Pantsuits rule ! German Workers National Zocialist Party = NAZIs were socialists too .

    Comment by Joeyk@optonline.net — March 1, 2017 @ 4:53 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: